From NYT columnist Frank Bruni's newsletter (via email) re Judge Amy Coney Barrett.
"How can I expect her [Barrett] to grant me the dignity that I, an agnostic gay man with no children but one really awesome dog, deserve if I don’t grant her the dignity that she, a mother of seven who ascribes to a conservative strain of Catholicism, has equal (but no greater) claim to? If I want her to understand me, I must be willing to understand her."
So how will we know if either Bruni or Barrett grants the other the dignity that they both have equal claim to? It might be easier to find out about Bruni's grant of dignity to Barrett than the other way around, at least if Barrett becomes a justice. We would theoretically be able to read Bruni's comments about Barrett's opinions(in the media). But the other way around? Barrett may not know anything about Bruni. I think he is alluding to her anticipated rulings about gay rights. Some would show a grant of dignity; others would not.
ReplyDelete